Strategic Negotiations | IT Outsourcing | Licensing Software | SW Implementation | Print Outsourcing | Computer Leasing | IT Pre-Nup's

 
Relations Management Group
  Strategic Negotiations IT Outsourcing Licensing Software Software Implementation  
Print Outsourcing Computer Leasing IT Pre-Nup's Testimonials
   
   


WE DO IT when we agree to get married to protect our personal assets, yet when we enter a business agreement we fail to protect our corporate you-know-whats! It’s the prenuptial agreement, a negotiable little contract whose terms govern rights and responsibilities should the big contract - marriage or outsourcing - not work out.

When You Outsource

Take outsourcing: the vendor buys your processing equipment, transfers your software licenses and hires your subject matter experts to run the show. If the deal goes sour or ends naturally, consider the complications in disentangling yourself from an IT outsourcing “marriage.”

A “pre-nup” can ease your divorce, providing a smooth, cheaper return of the business back to the company or to another outsourcer if the benefits become short-lived, the costs start to escalate or the business model undergoes a material change. If you can’t walk away by virtue of either a “Termination for Cause” or “Termination for Convenience” clause and survive, then you’re at the mercy of the vendor.

The outsourcer has to be contractually committed not to hold your assets for ransom and also to assist you in the “turnback” to ensure a minimal disruption of the services.

Thomas R. Mylott III, in Computer Outsourcing, Managing the Transfer of Information Systems, outlines both the legal and practical strategies that are necessary. Especially important for turnback is to establish your right to the following:

  • Your data on magnetic media and description of the data’s layout
  • Your software
  • The vendor’s cooperation
  • The vendor’s assistance
  • The vendor’s disclosure of technical information necessary or useful for the transition back
  • A license for the software owned by the outsourcing vendor for which you will have a continuing need
  • A license for software from a third party, but supplied by the outsourcing vendor, for which you will have a continuing need

On the Rocks

Agreements for systems implementation or software development deals can be a nightmare when you are forced to end them before completion. The client has typically spent an enormous amount of time and effort educating the vendor to build the required system and the vendor has spent an equal amount of time learning. Neither party will recoup these losses in the event of a failed project. By the time you get the bad news - late, overbudget, under-specifications - you’re typically several “M&M’s” (months and millions) into the build. Did you negotiate the right to cancel after exhausting the financial penalties? Do they keep the money you’ve paid them to date?


Can you take the work they’ve completed to date and give it to another service provider? Can they keep the custom-coded pieces and re-sell them to another client?

The vendor will likely have a limit of liability clause to minimize or eliminate the damages that they may be responsible for in the event of a failed project. The burden is on the client to ask the question, prior to the award of the contract, “what if it doesn’t work?” Keep asking that question until you get satisfactory answers and build the answers into the contractual commitments as though you were preparing an enforceable divorce decree.

When You Lease

The pre-nup principle also applies to something as innocent-looking as a hardware leasing agreement. What if the Lessor isn’t as generous on the lease rate when the first upgrade comes along? You don’t own the equipment so you can’t make changes to it without consent and that could come at a high cost
from an opportunistic Lessor.

The leasing scenario becomes further complicated by the ever-popular operating lease and the fair-market-value (FMV) purchase option. When you upgrade, you increase the value of the asset that you will most likely end up purchasing for FMV as determined by the Lessor. At a minimum you’re going to waste a lot of time scrambling to protect your interests if you haven’t worked it out in advance.

The pre-nuptial in this case comes in the form of a “buy-out”. Cap the FMV at a reasonable amount in the beginning and have the option to buy out the lease at a cost equal to the present value (PV) of the remaining stream of payments and the FMV cap. You retain the right to walk away from the lessor keeping your options open and your rates low. The Lessor is also protected with a small interest penalty embedded in the rate used for the PV calculation.

Unlike marriage, which unfortunately does end in divorce far too often, you have the advantage with IT agreements - you know you’ll get divorced! Plan on it and get a pre-nup.

 

 

Strategic Negotiations | IT Outsourcing | Licensing Software | SW Implementation | Print Outsourcing | Computer Leasing | IT Pre-Nup's

RELATIONS MANAGEMENT GROUP
50 Prince Arthur Ave., Suite 1603
Toronto, ON, M5R 1B5
Phone: (416) 920-2228
Email:
phil.downe@itnegotiations.com